Earth Rated Poop Bags Review: Are They Really the Best?

244,902 Amazon reviews at 4.8 stars. That's the Earth Rated Poop Bag's track record — and it's the most reviewed poop bag on the market by a significant margin. But does a product with that many reviews actually deserve a 4.8 rating, or has it just been around long enough to accumulate numbers?

I've been using Earth Rated bags for three years with Mochi, and I have strong opinions.

What Makes Earth Rated Different

Earth Rated bags are made from a thicker material than most competitors — you can feel the difference immediately when you pull one off the roll. The extra thickness is the key feature: it means you can grab the bag confidently without worrying about it tearing or having a "finger through the bag" moment (every dog owner's nightmare).

The lavender scent is real and noticeable — not overwhelming, but enough to make the experience significantly more pleasant. They also offer an unscented version for owners who prefer it.

Each roll contains 15 bags, and the 270-count pack gives you 18 rolls. The bags are made with 65% recycled materials, which is a genuine environmental benefit.

The Thickness Test

I tested Earth Rated bags against Amazon Basics bags (the most popular budget alternative) by filling each with a similar amount of material and applying pressure. The Earth Rated bags held up significantly better — the Amazon Basics bags showed stress marks at the seams under pressure, while the Earth Rated bags remained intact.

This isn't a scientific test, but it reflects real-world use: Earth Rated bags are meaningfully thicker and more reliable.

The Scent

The lavender scent is the feature that divides opinion most. Some owners love it; others find it unnecessary. I'm firmly in the "love it" camp — after three years of multiple daily pickups, having a bag that smells like lavender rather than nothing makes a real difference to my quality of life.

If you prefer unscented, Earth Rated makes an unscented version that's equally thick and reliable.

Value Comparison

Earth Rated costs about $0.02 more per bag than Amazon Basics. For the thickness and scent improvement, that's worth it to me — but if budget is your primary concern, Amazon Basics are adequate.

Verdict

4.8/5 stars. Earth Rated poop bags fully deserve their reputation as the best poop bags on the market. The extra thickness, lavender scent, and eco-friendly materials make them worth the small premium over budget alternatives. If you're going to buy one poop bag brand and stick with it, make it Earth Rated.