Top 5 Dog Toys for Chewers and Fetch Lovers

Finding a toy that survives an aggressive chewer is one of the great challenges of dog ownership. I've gone through dozens of toys with Mochi over the years — stuffed animals that were destroyed in minutes, rubber toys that cracked, rope toys that became choking hazards. These five have proven themselves.

1. Best Pet Supplies Crinkle Duck — Best Squeaky Toy

Featured Product

Best Pet Supplies Crinkle Duck Squeaky Toy (Large)

View on Amazon

The Crinkle Duck from Best Pet Supplies is the #14 best-selling dog toy on Amazon, and it's earned its place. The crinkle material makes a satisfying sound that drives dogs wild, and the squeaker adds an extra layer of excitement. It's not designed for aggressive chewers — it's a fetch and play toy — but for dogs who love to carry things around and squeak them, it's perfect.

The large size is substantial enough that it's not a choking hazard for medium and large dogs, and the crinkle material is surprisingly durable for a plush toy.

Best for: Fetch lovers, dogs who love to carry toys, moderate chewers.

Price: $5.99 — exceptional value.

2. KONG Classic — Best for Treat Stuffing

Featured Product

KONG Classic Dog Toy (Large)

View on Amazon

The KONG Classic is the most iconic dog toy ever made, and for good reason. The natural rubber construction is virtually indestructible for most dogs, and the hollow center can be stuffed with treats, peanut butter, or kibble to create hours of mental stimulation. We've reviewed the KONG Classic in detail — see our full KONG Classic review for everything you need to know.

Best for: Aggressive chewers, dogs with separation anxiety, mental stimulation.

3. Benebone Bacon Flavored Wishbone — Best for Power Chewers

Featured Product

Benebone Bacon Flavored Wishbone (Large)

View on Amazon

The Benebone Wishbone is our top pick for power chewers. The nylon construction is extremely durable, and the wishbone shape allows dogs to hold it with their paws while chewing — which is how dogs naturally prefer to chew. The real bacon flavor is infused throughout the nylon, so it stays interesting even as the surface wears down.

We've reviewed the Benebone in detail — see our full Benebone review for the complete breakdown.

Best for: Power chewers, dogs who need long-lasting chew satisfaction.

4. Nylabone DuraChew — Best Budget Chew Toy

Featured Product

Nylabone DuraChew Textured Ring (Large)

View on Amazon

The Nylabone DuraChew is the most affordable durable chew toy on this list, and it's been a trusted brand for decades. The textured surface helps clean teeth as your dog chews, and the nylon construction is designed to last for months of regular chewing. We've reviewed the Nylabone DuraChew X in detail — see our full Nylabone review.

Best for: Moderate to heavy chewers on a budget.

5. Chuckit! Ultra Ball — Best Fetch Toy

Featured Product

Chuckit! Ultra Ball (Large)

View on Amazon

For dogs who love to fetch, the Chuckit! Ultra Ball is the best ball on the market. It's made from high-bounce natural rubber that's significantly more durable than a standard tennis ball, and it's designed to work with the Chuckit! launcher for maximum throwing distance. The high-visibility colors make it easy to find in grass and water.

Best for: Fetch-obsessed dogs, water-loving dogs, high-energy breeds.

How to Choose the Right Toy for Your Dog

The key is matching the toy to your dog's play style and chew intensity. A light chewer who loves to carry things needs a different toy than a power chewer who destroys everything in sight. When in doubt, start with a KONG — it works for almost every dog.